"The call, from what I remember, was very frantic," said Greenburgh Police Detective Richard Constantino. SHOP NOW Match Game cast list, including photos of the actors when available. "It turned out to be true because she had been dating a man for eight years," said Warmus. "She was on her way to see Paul Solomon," said attorney William Aronwald. But they did find that gun shop records showed one of Warmus's co-workers bought bullets on the day of the murder. May we not wait until the end of our lives to draw the same conclusion. Who is still alive from the group Peter, Paul and Mary? Waiting for your permission to load facebook comments. gaffer (24 episodes, 1990-1992) "Mr. Solomon, you have no idea who was in that house that killed your wife, right?". "In comes the prosecution, and they say 'Judge, we have a glove, a missing piece of evidence. Paul Solomon is an American teacher and ex-lover of the convicted killer, Carolyn Warmus. amazon.co.uk He claimed that if the seed matched anyone other than Solomon, it would tip the scales in Warmus favor. "I would have liked to have had a signed confession. "He pretty much made himself a suspect by his demeanor, the way he spoke, and to be pretty honest with you, I was really leaning towards him being the shooter," said Constantino. "Nothing in the media portrayed me well," Carolyn Warmus tells Crime Watch Daily. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. But the official bill from MCI showed that it came from your home at 3 o'clock. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. So what did you think of that comparison, and how much do you think it prejudiced your case? It just doesn't make sense.". Peaky Blinders fans have been given a glimmer of hope that Alfie Solomons (Tom Hardy) may actually still be alive after the penultimate episode of this season. Kelly thought it would be appropriate to test the semen, as Betty Jane Solomon was known to have an affair. ", "What I know will judge me is perhaps not a court of law, and rightfully so, because a court of law shouldn't judge me for this. Naturally, viewers were sent into a speculative frenzy, with one particularly excited fan tweeting: "OH MY F***ING GOD IS ALFIE ALIVE??! And the glove immediately whipped up a storm in the courtroom. The courts reasoning ignored the most compelling assumption in this murder: the person wearing the gloves was the murderer, Kelly wrote. King Solomon and the apostle Paul are two men in Scripture, one from the Old Testament and one from the New, who played significant roles in the outworking of events that shaped history. At the moment of writing, we know that he was a New-York teacher whose wife has been murdered by his ex-girlfriend. An example of data being processed may be a unique identifier stored in a cookie. Currently, we dont have any information regarding his educational journey. - Died: 1988 in Los Angeles, USA.) BBC Source: celebritiesbuzz.com.gh Checkout: Dead Or Alive Related posts was a British orchestra leader, arranger and music director, most known for his . "Our first suspect was Paul Solomon," said Constantino. But Warmus admits she indulged in a very different kind of life outside of the classroom, wallowing in the free-wheeling excesses of the anything-goes roaring '80s. Among them, police say, was another man who took legal action to stop her from stalking him and his fiance. Some say that someone murdered him and took his body into hiding in order to cover up their crime; others suggest that he simply left on his own accord because he was unhappy with how things were going with his family and wanted something new. Kathy was an actress and the couple had one son, Adrian, before they divorced in 1965. Peaky Blinders - The Complete Collection [DVD] Got a showbiz story? While serving out this mission, he married Kathryn Grove Halliday (1850-1933) on November 24th, 1878 in her hometown in Michigan where they raised four children together: Pauline (1880), Clara Maudie Ellen(1882), John Franklin Stewart(1888) and Helen Lucile(1893). Is Paul Solomon Still Alive or Dead? According to wide reports, Adrian is a music producer and has been in a relationship with Dannii since at least 2014. Paul Solomons: Lucky in Love. After being discharged from service he returned home where he met and married Audrey Anderson who gave birth to two sons Gary and Ronald before divorcing him when he left for California where she remained behind with their children until moving out west herself some years later due to marriage problems between her husband Jim Arnold (also known by his nickname Pig) and girlfriend Donna Barlowe.. When Paul Solomon still walked among us, he taught a wonderful course that he called Inner Light Consciousness. 4.99 The prosecution and defense had both wanted the glove for the first trial, and Paul Solomon had been implored to look for it. It is clearly evident that God will hold true to His word, no matter who we are, where we are, or what place of prominence, rule of power, or influential presence we possess. In 1989, a New York teacher named Paul Solomon had become famous after being related to Carolyn Warmus, an American former elementary school teacher convicted at the age of 28 of killing her lovers wife, Betty Jeanne Solomon. He might be using social media under some anonymous names is what we can assume. Is Cassandra Delaney Still Alive Or Dead. So there are a lot of similarities to your case here? I would have liked to have had a giant stadium filled with witnesses, but we didn't.". The net worth of Paul Solomon is under the wraps. Photis and videos leaked onlyfans. It was a completely circumstantial case," said Carolyn Warmus. She was subjected to a number of affirmed disciplinary movements, which have been raised throughout her first parole denial in early 2017. . The tests were initially approved in 2017 by then-acting District Attorney James McCarty. Paul Solomon had dumped Carolyn Warmus for another female teacher soon after his wife's murder. We did meet at school functions," said Warmus. Warmus claims she has a brain tumor that is not malignant, but still life-threatening, as it continues to grow. I know what my family and friends and people who know me believe," Solomon said on the stand. Even as Alfie admitting he was riddled with cancer, the pairs love/hate relationship has become a firm favourite plot for the ever-complicated Birmingham boys. But it was never collected as evidence after tests with white malachite failed to detect blood. His friends explain that while he was gone, they heard that they are all going to Russia. You can email the site owner to let them know you were blocked. But Richard Constantino, the lead detective in the Betty Jeanne Solomon murder case, has just as steadfastly maintained that Carolyn Warmus did kill Paul Solomon's wife. But the judge refused to allow forensic testing, stating there didn't appear to be enough blood for DNA testing, and saying the glove's whereabouts can't be verified during the time it was missing. 210.65.88.143 This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. In 1989, a New York teacher named Paul Solomon had become famous after being related to Carolyn Warmus, an American former elementary school teacher convicted at the age of 28 of killing her lover's wife, Betty Jeanne Solomon. But undoubtedly the biggest reveal came at the end of the episode, when Tommy (Cillian Murphy) seemed to hint that Tom Hardy's Alfie Solomon could still be alive. "Oh definitely, definitely. We earn a commission for products purchased through some links in this article. Betty Jeanne Solomon, the wife of her ex-lover, had been shot.Paul Solomon Carolyn Warmus lifeless, DNA testing of proof from 1989 slaying The TalksToday https://t.co/K6pTfZRONj viral bihar (@viralbihar4) March 27, 2022, Paul Solomon Carolyn Warmus lifeless, DNA testing of proof from 1989 slaying The TalksToday https://t.co/K6pTfZRONj. BBC This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Paul Williams, subject of the documentary Paul Williams Still Alive, wrote some of the most enduring songs of the '70s including "Rainbow Connection" from The Muppet Movie. *From the conduct of Solomon and his practises, it is conceivable, and believed, that much of his concluding wisdom and fear of the LORD was not practised during his lifetime, but was the conclusion drawn by him at the end of his life, when it seems that he then repented before the LORD for his sin and evil deeds. But something strange happened hundreds of miles away that suddenly made Carolyn Warmus the focus of the investigation. When Solomon returned home that night, he found his wifes body. "How do we know this is the same glove from the crime scene photos? He is still alive but has maintained a low profile because some people believe he killed his wife and framed Carolyn for the murder. "I try to look to the future. "We don't know where the glove was all this time.". Recently, his wife has been killed by his ex-girlfriend. He was found dead in his home by a family member. "And your family and your friends are the people over the years you've had occasion to look in the eye and lie to, right?". Note: It is suggested to read the events in completeness in order to gain a complete overview and true perspective of what Ive put down in point form above, as selective scriptures can isolate the points, but not give a total overview. said Aronwald. "Oh, I think it was huge prejudice, huge prejudice," said Warmus. Two years ago, Warmus was released on parole after serving 27 years in prison for the Jan. 15, 1989 shooting death of victim, Betty Jeanne Solomon, at the Fort Greene townhouse. Popular: Who is Nhlanhla Lux Dlamini? If you would like to change your settings or withdraw consent at any time, the link to do so is in our privacy policy accessible from our home page.. In Edgemont, he became a teacher at Greenville Elementary School. In 1990, Warmus was charged with second-degree murder. Besides, Warmus was an elementary school teacher in Westchester County, New York, at the time, and had started an affair with Paul Solomon, a 17 years . ", OH MY FUCKING GOD IS ALFIE ALIVE??! Jimmy laughed off the suggestion, and told Tommy: Hes dead, and hes Jewish. Lead detective Richard Constantino recalls it having blood on it. Paul Solomon was the oldest son of Ernie and Pearl Solomon, who lived next door to each other in St George Utah (they were married for 60 years). However, many others believe that his death was a punishment from God because he didnt obeyed God in the last years of his life. The first resolved last week's dramatic cliffhanger, in which Linda Shelby (Kate Phillips) was shot by Polly after threatening to kill her husband Arthur. Why are they opposed to it?" She was shot nine times but managed to call 911 briefly, although the dispatcher wasnt sure if she said he or she trying to kill her. "I never had a gun to dispose of," said Warmus. On January 15, 1989, Solomon found his wife dead in their home at Greenburghcondominium. "We did. Paul Solomon attended school at Brigham Young Academy before being called into missionary service with The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS). However, I think this is probably due to filter effects and poor camera quality. Strictly's Karen Hauer teases future judging role, Creed 3 star talks building intimacy with co-star, EastEnders reveals big twist in Eve and Suki story, Emmerdale star shares future of Paddy's dark story, Sims 4 Growing Together 28% off in pre-order deal. She also ordered that glove evidence discovered by her ex-lover Paul Solomon between the first and second trials be tested for DNA. Is that true? It's not even something that I would consider," said Warmus. From Arthur Shelby to Gina Gray, the suspects so far, MORE : Peaky Blinders season 5: How Lizzie could be key to Tommy Shelby getting over Grace, Gary ONeil names the best team in the Premier League and reacts to Arsenals celebrations against Bournemouth, Mikel Arteta explains why he brought on Reiss Nelson for Emile Smith Rowe in dramatic Arsenal win, Richard Keys raises concern over Arsenals dramatic winner against Bournemouth, Prince Harry says weed really helped his mental health, Harry says British soldiers werent necessarily supportive of Afghanistan military efforts, Tommys even been looking after Alfies (Tom Hardy) dog Cyril, Peaky Blinders season 5: Who is the Black Cat? Paul Solomon was also one of the most controversial figures in Utahs history hated by many Mormons but respected by others. Kathy was Paul Simon's first wife. The pair have been tight-lipped about the exact details of how they met and fell in love. --Bill Shepherd (Born: 13 June 1927 in Merstham, Surrey, UK. document.getElementById("ak_js_1").setAttribute("value",(new Date()).getTime()); Obituary: Who was Manika Naidoo? Please include what you were doing when this page came up and the Cloudflare Ray ID found at the bottom of this page. still photographer (25 episodes, 1985-1986) Jim Orthel . Many have been searching for Paul Solomon since the 1980s when he disappeared without a trace from the community where he had lived for nearly 50 years. Tommy Shelby ( Cillian Murphy . Did you ever dispose of the gun? People are curious to discover more about the New York instructor after his ex-lover, who murdered his wife, was released after serving 27 years in prison. One of these was a seven-part journal that he called The Journal Of the Mystery Schools, a journal that students could use to . But the Fatal Attraction Murder case pulled back Solomon again into the limelight, and people began searching for his current status. I try to look forward. Solomon testified against his ex-lover since was given immunity by the District Attorney, however, the trial ended in a hung jury. Chapter 9: After returning from his leave, Paul sees that his friends are still alive. We and our partners use cookies to Store and/or access information on a device. In the episode's closing scenes, Tommy paid a visit to Jimmy McCavern (Brian Gleeson) at the docks to discuss who would be controlling the North and South tracks. "I believe from my understanding there was blood specks were found on the glove," said Constantino. Paul Solomon could still be alive, as none of the verifiable sources have revealed anything about his death. "These new lab employees supposedly said that so many people have handled the glove -- jurors, district attorneys, people in the lab and stuff -- that it would be more difficult to get a pure DNA sample," said Warmus. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Nor could the prosecution find any witnesses. Absolutely. It was just circumstantial evidence, as is everything else with the case.". He is still alive but has maintained a low profile because some people believe he killed his wife and framed Carolyn for the murder. She says it could turn out to be her last testament. "Then they got a second statement which showed another discrepancy. A weeping Carolyn Warmus called Paul Solomon, still dazed from his wife's death, to complain that he wasn't paying attention to her, testimony showed Monday. Trending: Obituary: Dr. Cat Pause, Fat Studies scholar, Wikipedia, Aged 30s, Death Cause, Weight, Family. Just like the weapon police say she used to murder Betty Jeanne Solomon, the wife of Warmus's lover, Paul Solomon. William Aronwald, her defense attorney in that retrial, was shocked too. Paul Solomon (7 July 1939 - 4 March 1994) was a professed psychic and seer who claimed to channel answers to questions asked of him from a metaphysical "Source". Following their wedding, the couple moved to Alaska, where Paul was stationed as an Air Force officer. Peaky Blinders: Series 1 I took one big thing away from this week's #PeakyBlinders and it's that I think Alfie's still alive somewhere. Continue with Recommended Cookies. "It was bizarre.". Who was Paul Simon's Kathy? And police say an insanely jealous and furious Warmus had followed Solomon and his new girlfriend all the way from New York to Puerto Rico, where they had gone for a romantic getaway, Warmus frantically trying to confront Solomon face to face. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". He said after his daughter finished high school," said Warmus. What is causing the plague in Thebes and how can it be fixed? Paul Simon Dead Or Still Alive. How old was King Solomon when he died? "I know that she did -- she did this homicide," Constantino tells Crime Watch Daily. As per CNN, Warmus was convicted guilty of murdering Solomon following a relationship with Betty's husband Paul Solomon, in a scene that resembled the 1987 Glenn Close movie Fatal Attraction. SHOP NOW. He married in 1959 and had a daughter (Sharon Dove). Travers is survived by her fourth husband, Ethan Robbins, and daughters Alicia and Erika. "She made numerous phone call attempts to his room that he didn't respond to, and when he refused to see her, the security people in the hotel said that she was acting strange," said Constantino. Just hit 'Like' on our Digital Spy Facebook page and 'Follow' on our @digitalspy Instagram and Twitter accounts. MORE : Peaky Blinders season 5: Who is the Black Cat? When Jimmy tells him that Oswald is up for suggestion over who should lead, Tommy responded: I would suggest the most competent organiser of men in the south, is Alfie Solomons.. But once again, proving her innocence comes down to testing that mysterious glove found at the crime scene. "And I can't understand why the D.A. But a truck driver named Antonio Gambino testified that Parco had tried to hire him to commit a murder just before Mrs. Solomon was found shot dead. And Deskovic has hired attorney Dennis Kelly to try to get Warmus one last appeal. "Everybody was a suspect at the time, but they were eventually ruled out," said Constantino. When the two started having an affair, Warmus was a young teacher under Solomons tutelage at Greenville Elementary School in Edgemont. Copyright 2023 MRandom News | Powered by NewsRandom, Michael Rhodes dead and obituary, Joe Bonamassa band members, Great guitarist David Lindley dead and obituary, Whats happened, Best brands of Hookahs and where to buy them, Hareem shah Lic colgate tooth paste viral video leaked on twitter, F1nn5ter leaked OF on twitter and reddit, Finnster Onlyf, Nikocado Avocado is dead or still alive? Following her initial denial of parole in early 2017, she was confronted with a number of affirmed disciplinary consequences, to which she was sentenced. "Nobody wants to describe it in its entirety.". The consent submitted will only be used for data processing originating from this website. He called police. "He claimed that he searched high and low, every square inch of the apartment. Paul Solomon died on December 6th, 2018, at the age of 90. Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. He was hated by many Mormons but respected by others, and his disappearance from the community where he had lived for nearly 50 years without leaving a trace shocked his neighbors. Dannii now describes herself as a proud mum, 5ft2 fashion designer [for QVC] and panellist on Masked Singer Australia. Carolyn Warmus had already been branded the killer in the court of public opinion. SHOP NOW This list includes all of the Match Game main actors and actresses, so if they are an integral part of the show you'll find them below.You can various bits of trivia about these Match Game stars, such as where the actor was born and what their year of birth is. Paul Solomon was removedfrom classroom duties and was assigned non-teaching duties in 1991 for having multiple affairs with his colleagues. Paul Solomon/Living or Deceased, Julian McMahonm. What Happened To Paul Solomon?- Is New York Teacher Still Alive? SHOP NOW Yes, both Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel are still alive. Did he have any family members after his death? "I don't see how in any way shape or form it ever should have been introduced into evidence at the second trial," said appeals attorney Dennis Kelly. Surprisingly, even the lead detective on the case agrees. But then the prosecution dropped an unexpected bombshell: phone company records showed a call from Warmus's home to a gun shop in New Jersey on the very day of Mrs. Solomon's murder. Did you kill Betty Jeanne Solomon? Did you make that call to Ray's Sports Shop? In 1992, she was convicted after a second trial in which the only new evidence was gloves. They were married from 1957-1972. 19941995 "As far as the public's perception was concerned, I'm not sure she presented a very favorable image," said William Aronwald, Warmus's defense attorney. She even considered divorce, but finally decided to stay in the marriage. And the defense suggests that possible "he" could have been Vincent Parco. Peaky Blinders tourism attraction being investigated for Birmingham, Peaky Blinders tourism attraction being investigated for Birmingham. "If the DNA comes back for the blood as somebody else's DNA, then that's the killer," said Warmus. Answer (1 of 10): Billy Shears, aka William Campbell, aka Billy Shepherd was a real person. "They say they can test it. "He was very sheepish.". Constantino could understand why after talking to those who knew him. "They tried the case in the media.". Police also uncovered other evidence against Carolyn Warmus. I was just in shock," said Warmus. The group won five Grammy Awards for its three-part harmony for "Leaving on a Jet Plane," "Puff the Magic Dragon" and Bob Dylan's "Blowin' in the Wind.". "I was very friendly with Carolyn. Authority, power, influence, and wealth outside of obedience to God has the potential of being a very strong cocktail for destruction. Also, he was born in Newark, New Jersey, United States, on October 13, 1941, to Hungarian-Jewish parents. Absolutely not," said Warmus. For whatever reason, she pushed the right buttons, or I didn't think properly," private detective Vincent Parco said on the stand during the trial. Paul Williams Still Alive -- Official Trailer PaulWilliamsFanatic 200 subscribers Subscribe 289 44K views 10 years ago If you know who Paul Williams is I made this film for you. If you would like to change your settings or withdraw consent at any time, the link to do so is in our privacy policy accessible from our home page.. The internet has been humming with rumors concerning Paul Solomon's whereabouts. 'Red Right Hand' by Nick Cave [Theme from Peaky Blinders] "The jury was hung eight to four in favor of conviction," said William Aronwald. Your email address will not be published. Rambert/Birmingham Hippodrome/The Lowry/Caryn Mandabach Productions In 1970, Paul Solomon married Betty Jeanne Solomon in Nyack. But undoubtedly the biggest reveal came at the end of the episode, when Tommy (Cillian Murphy) seemed to hint that Tom Hardy's Alfie Solomon could still be alive. "Well now, I certainly have a lot of questions," said Warmus. But she continued to maintain her innocence and tried to check three pieces of evidence to see if they could prove her innocence by naming another suspect. Then the defense raised the possibility the killer may have even been a man, pointing to a phone call made from the Solomon home at the time police say Betty Jeanne Solomon was being murdered. "She basically has testified that she never had any need for the gun," said William Aronwald. Another piece of evidence was the victim's semen and blood found in the handbag of the victim's husband, paul solomon. 31.80 (18% off) Further, no info on his current profession has been made public for now. Warmus says Paul Solomon told her his wife was also having an affair with his knowledge and approval. And so little attention was paid to the glove found at the crime scene that it's not even clear if it was a man's or a woman's glove. There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data. But there are some serious questions about the glove, which the defense claimed suddenly appeared to have a lot of blood on it that wasn't there when it was found at the crime scene. Required fields are marked *. By In Touch Staff. "We did a reciprocal restraining order, that he was not going to come near me, my family, the office or anything like that. Warner Bros. Entertainment | Carolyn Warmus walked out of Bedford Hills Correctional Facility on June 17, 2019, 27 years after she was sentenced to 25 years to life in prison for murder. After news of his infidelity spread, Paul Solomon was removed from the classroom and assigned to non-teaching duties. Netizens are eager to know updates on the New York teacher after his ex-lover, who killed his wife, was out after serving 27 years in prison. "I was already dating him and that was certainly a huge mistake by me to continue dating him, and to not have ended it right then and there," said Warmus. Parents, Biography, Family, Wiki, Aged 35, Fat Studies scholar, Dr. Cat Pause, Died at Aged mid 30s, Cause of Death, Family and Husband, Too Close to Touch Lead Singer, Keaton Pierce passed away, Cause of Death, Birthday, Wife. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads. However, after the birth of their daughter Kristan in 1973, they relocated to Harrison, New York. But now she's finally agreed to have it done while incarcerated, even though she comes up for parole again this summer. And you were intimate in the parking lot in the car? Is New York Teacher Still Alive? This content is imported from Twitter. We really hope to know more about him in the future. We will update this section as soon as more information about him are available on the media. Peaky Blinders - The Original Soundtrack So that's what that was about," said Warmus. We didnt find him on any social media handles like Twitter, Facebook, Instagram etc. She had been pistol-whipped and shot, with nine bullets in her body, three of them in her back. This course described several tools that could be used for spiritual growth and character development. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics". The Grammys paid tribute to legendary singer-songwriter Paul Simon this year, but his former bandmate, Art Garfunkel, did not join him on stage leading some to wonder if Garfunkel is still alive. She is one of the current judges on The Masked Singer Australia. The prosecution wanted forensic tests conducted on the glove, hoping blood belonging to Carolyn Warmus will be found. "I would like to have had a smoking gun," said Richard Constantino, lead detective on the case. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. The date of birth, age, and star sign of Solomon is not available at the moment. A black glove, described as leather, was found near the body while police were dealing with the crime scene. Next week, in the season five finale, Tommy and Arthur (Paul Anderson) are going to need all the help they can get as they prepare to assassinate Mosley and take down the Billy Boys. amazon.co.uk The defense claims Parco changed his story to save himself from being prosecuted. Paul Solomon's ex-lover Carolyn . Both were chosen of God, both had prominent positions, both were instrumental and influential in their spheres of operation, and both had a profound and lasting impact upon their immediate and distant . If youre a startup, you know that its not easy to get your product out there. Peaky Blinders continues next Sunday at 9pm on BBC One. To view the purposes they believe they have legitimate interest for, or to object to this data processing use the vendor list link below. When did Paul Solomon get married and have a daughter? Abramorama hide caption BBC. So they introduced two computer copies or something that actually contradicted themselves, and then there was, the actual hard bill, the printed bill on paper.". "This is vital evidence that could identify the person who killed Betty Jeanne Solomon," said Aronwald. Who Was Paul Simon'S Kathy? "We all wanted to test it," said Carolyn Warmus. Lets take a look from the time they were called by God, and see what the final conclusion drawn from their lives is. Amazon #PeakyBlinders. Next episode will hopefully reveal all Peaky Blinders season 5 airs on Sundays at 9pm on BBC One. Paul Solomon Carolyn Warmus dead, DNA testing of evidence from 1989 slaying / omg / By memes127en Westchester County prosecutors have approved DNA testing as evidence that contributed to the 1992 conviction of Carolyn Warmus for the so-called "Fatal Attraction" murder of her lover's wife. Mute Records SHOP NOW Paul Solomon may be alive as none of the verified sources have mentioned the details regarding his demise. From Arthur Shelby to Gina Gray, the suspects so far, Peaky Blinders season 5: How Lizzie could be key to Tommy Shelby getting over Grace, Do not sell or share my personal information. Sure enough, when Paul Solomon's hands were tested for residue that might have placed the murder weapon in his hands --. In 1963, Solomons wife left him; the couple later divorced. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. Before the second trial, Solomon found a black cashmere glove in the closet and handed it over to the prosecution.